Rachel Maddow High School Photo A Fake?

Apparently David Vitter looked just like Rachel Maddow in his High School yearbook.

 

 

People is anyone questioning the photo of Rachel Maddow's alleged femmery that has been circling the the interwebs like a a bad clown rodeo? Or have we all accepted lock stock and smoking barrel the wizardry of Photoshop?

rachel maddow high school picture

Give a kid a couple Google images and 10 minutes...

I hate conspiracy theories, but in everyone's race to de-butch a butch, or demean a women by saying she looks like a man (someone please explain why this is even an insult, I just find it juvenile) has anyone verified the authenticity of this alleged high school photo of Rachel Maddow? bloggers from CNN to WaPo have jumped on this bandwagon. As far as I can tell the story originate with a site called Unamericana, a chronicle of American Stupidity. Um yeah, really credible journalism there guys.

Okay maybe I'm wrong. Maybe Rachel Maddow was a young debutant in High School. However, that certainly doesn't match up with her own description of herself in high school as "a cross between the jock and the antisocial girl." Here's Maddow at 21, in a profile for Out Magazine after she received her Rhodes Scholarship. Okay, a lot can happen to a kid between 18 and 21...

But I dunno, I just don't buy it.

Oh funny thing is I just found my yearbook photo and I also looked just like Rachel Maddow at 18.

Comments [25]

karrr's picture

anyways...i kind of hope it

anyways...i kind of hope it was her. cool 360

karrr's picture

who cares?

who cares?

Erika Davis's picture

I think it's her

In high school, I had straight hair, I was "straight" and I looked like a cheerleader and the president of the class-because I was... Smile  

rovermom's picture

I think it could be

I think it could be believable.

From what I have read, Rachel's hometown was very conservative. She looks like a teenage female, from a middle class family...and Californian to boot. And possible even jocky.

Gooing from high school to college can drastically change someone's appearance...kids finally let their freedom and rebelling fly. Especially when coming out screaming...heads get shaved..and dyed...standing up and shoving in faces of who they are.......seriously, I say it's totally believable.

I say Rachel is gorgeous...either as a long haird blonde or as the gentle butch she has relaxed into being.

Robin Rigby's picture

That pic with Moon's face is

That pic with Moon's face is really disturbing me. 

Become a fan of "Sodomy: The Musical" on Facebook!
http://www.facebook.com/pages/Sodomy-The-Musical/302006935414

Not2Taem's picture

Stroke?

I think because it came from her flash picture it kind of looks like she had a stroke.

Grace Moon's picture

c'mon!

look that was 2 sec photoshop give a girl a break!

tweet tweet @gracemoon

Not2Taem's picture

I was!

I thought you made it look freakish on purpose. Now fork over a nice genteel artist type pic for us to play with. It will translate better, not that you would be all that hard to femme up.

Robin Rigby's picture

I need to upload that pic of

I need to upload that pic of me with long, curly hair & no glasses (even though it was taken 3 years after I got glasses).

Become a fan of "Sodomy: The Musical" on Facebook!
http://www.facebook.com/pages/Sodomy-The-Musical/302006935414

Conlite's picture

You and Rachel both looked

You and Rachel both looked way cooler in high school than me!  Smile

Robin Rigby's picture

Cool? Me? Never. That pic is

Cool? Me? Never. That pic is actually from junior high. I was 13. It's the tragic perm pic.

Become a fan of "Sodomy: The Musical" on Facebook!
http://www.facebook.com/pages/Sodomy-The-Musical/302006935414

Conlite's picture

Yes, well then that should

Yes, well then that should give you a notion of how uncool I looked.  And you'll have to just wonder, because I certainly won't be uploading any photos from then!

Robin Rigby's picture

Aw come on!  I'll bet you

Aw come on!  I'll bet you were an adorable little marmot.*

*I hope I remembered the correct name for your little squirrely critter. Smile

Become a fan of "Sodomy: The Musical" on Facebook!
http://www.facebook.com/pages/Sodomy-The-Musical/302006935414

Conlite's picture

Right name, but "squirrely

Shy

Right name, but "squirrely critter" is fine too.  Its just internet security anyhows.

annemarlen's picture

funny

wondering where my high school photo is. And why is Rachel Maddow looking like Grace Moon at 18?

love is a pebble laughing in the sun

minniesota's picture

High school yearbook photos and other disasters

Hmmm, hmmmm. I wonder where my senior year high school year book photo is. I'm pretty sure I was wearing a dress but that was my high school all-girls Catholic high school days. Don't hold that fact against me, por favor!

Civility is not a sign of weakness.

yams's picture

wow

_

~ do you like peddle boats, lakes and brooklyn? http://prospectparklake.kintera.org/
~ dollytrolly.com 'help a dolly out!'
~ studiotangents.com 8 beat grooves...

SMBrown's picture

So we're to believe not only

So we're to believe not only was she femmy, but she was peroxiding as well in high school?  I didn't think anything of the hair color at first because most blonds start to lose their color in the mid-to-late twenties, and by thirtysomething they have to dye.  But between 18 and 21?  Really?   (said in an Amy Poehler incredulous voice)

Rockets's picture

Umm...

neck mole - IF it was photoshoped it was done by a genius. (I mean, I WOULDN'T have missed that detail obviously) but, usually it's simple screw ups that give away a fake. Like, missing moles or birthmarks.

Anyway - she's hot either way. Just sayin'

Visit the FREE Lesbian Coloring pages at ~ illustrocity.blogspot.com

KJ's picture

There should definitely be an

There should definitely be an automated tool for photoshopping your face/faces into that yearbook photo.

BambiG's picture

Senior shots are not indicative of who you are

It's obviously a senior photo (no one goes around wearing velvet cowels) who knows from this pic how she chose to dress everyday for school. Maybe in jeans and a ponytail or maybe in dresses. Who cares? Very few people dress as adults the way they did in high school.

Not2Taem's picture

LOL

I know I don't, mostly because it takes a true masochist to wear plaid flannel in Texas. That and the fact that all the plaid shirts I see these days seem to have ruffles.

Not2Taem's picture

tweet-tweet

A long time back RM tweeted about this photo. I don't remember what she said and wish I could find it, but I do remember that it did not sound like denial.It was on the side bar here for a while.

Someone with capabilities please work on Moon's pic. I'm sure there is something really precious to be mined there. Maybe something based on Marlow Thomas?   Evil

Uncle Aimee's picture

Leave femmy Maddow alone!

The years btw high school and college and the working world are dog years.  I had a femmy phase right out of college into work for a few months just to cover up my total homo-ness.  It didn't stick, obviously, but those photos still haunt me to this day.  A-hole guys still think I should go back to the long skirts & hair because apparently I'll attract the woman I'm looking for.  In reality, I'd only attract the woman I actually am.  But can you blame her for femming it up for a minute?  We all have our moments trying out new stuff...

Tex's picture

OMG! GM as a straight blonde!

And pearls......And that mole on the neck keeps jumping from side to side and disappearing all together.

Smile Smile Smile Smile