Late last week on The Rachel Maddow Show, in an example of thoughtfully fearless and perfectly honest effrontery, Rachel called someone “a parasite who gets fat on Americans' fears.” The guy in question was Tim Phillips, president of the right-wing activist group Americans for Prosperity which is going around the country hosting events in an effort to put the kibosh on health care reform through fear mongering. Maddow and Phillips faced off in two segments on Thursday night with Maddow following up with some clarifying points on Friday.
What she did not do in the follow-up was apologize... nor should she have. She actually said that, after having some distance, she felt exactly the same.
In the heat of the confrontation, Rachel saw that her guest was pushing it into the personal realm. She acknowledged that turn, paused, and responded with her truest impression of the person sitting across from her, leaving us with some indelible symbolism for a man she sees to be as something of a scourge. There was no vitriol or melodrama. Voices weren't raised and tears weren't shed. This was merely an act of someone on the liberal side of the aisle having a backbone and not being afraid to use it. (I would have said cojones, but Rachel gets enough of the ladyman jokes as it is.) Maddow saw a spade masquerading as a heart and said, “Hey, everybody, this right here is a spade.”
I don't know about you, but I've been waiting for an awfully long time for just such a push back against the lying, cheating, and stealing --- albeit, generally with a smile (or a noose) --- of the right. Sure, Keith Olbermann calls out the phonies on the regs, though not usually to their faces. But Keith is so self-righteously smug about it, I feel he's just like the blow-hards on FOX but with better information and smarter guests.
Having Rachel, in all her super-geek, policy wonk, community activist glory land a punch like that was phenomenal. It gives me hope to see someone who seems genuinely humble and caring speak truth to power, as it were. She didn't explode or melt or get fired, either, so let's hope she does it whenever the cause arises. And let's all take her cue, step into our glory and call out those spades when we see falsehoods or injustices in our own lives.
Tweet















Comments [10]
I
Saw this when it first aired last week,I don't know she had it in her.
I have found Rachel Maddow's
I have found Rachel Maddow's "Welsh male doppelganger". I am sure we all have one somewhere....
http://i.thisislondon.co.uk/i/pix/2008/11/gethin-jones-500x650.jpg
Steph, good catch. I'd love
Steph, good catch. I'd love to see what someone with PhotoShop skills can do with those two. He needs blue glasses.
"When you look for the bad in mankind expecting to find it, you surely will." ~ Pollyanna
She has lots!
I've seen her compared to a number of fellows: Tobey Maquire, Henry Thomas, et al.
I guess being handsome is sort of universal.
Won't you be my neighbor? @theKELword
I get that
I get that. I had to stop listening to Randi Rhodes for a similar reason. I usually agree with her and she has covers background information that most don't, but I just can't take her delivery any more.
[This was meant as a reply to Kelly. It placed wrong twice, no idea why]
"When you look for the bad in mankind expecting to find it, you surely will." ~ Pollyanna
Yeah, yeah!
I was never really able to get into Randi.
You think things like this are why Air America hasn't been tremendously successful?
Won't you be my neighbor? @theKELword
Air America
Randi got bounced from Air America, but progressive stations still air her show. I think Rachel going to TV and Franken going to the Senate were the big blows to Air America. I still listen to Ron Reagan sometimes.
"When you look for the bad in mankind expecting to find it, you surely will." ~ Pollyanna
Agreed
Any confrontational guest who says "sure" when she asks if they'll stick around until after the break is dumb as a rock. That is the gateway to Evisceration City.
I was afraid she was going to apologize and I'm thrilled she didn't. I want her to kick Spawn of Cheney ass next.
I'm a fan of Keith in all his smugness. His Special Comments are normally on target (the Marriage and Health Reform are his two best so far).
Rachel and Keith are my favorites because they don't pit guests against each other the way other shows do. I can't stand the crossfire approach.
"When you look for the bad in mankind expecting to find it, you surely will." ~ Pollyanna
No crossfire for me either.
Keith always has great information and good points to make, but I can't get past the arrogance. It taints his credibility for me. Took a while for that to happen, like a few months of watching regularly. And it makes me sad, actually, because I would like to absorb his info and opinions. Just can't.
Won't you be my neighbor? @theKELword
Me too
I had the same experience. I watched him for a few months and even though I usually agreed, I got tired of his on air personality. I do appreciate that he can laugh at himself though. I thought it was funny when he showed the SNL clip with Ben Affleck.